Dining in Venice, FL: 10 of Our Favorite Restaurants for New Residents to Try

by April Mackey Iliff

So, you've unpacked your boxes, felt the warm Florida sun on your face, and maybe even spotted your first shark tooth. Welcome to Venice! One of the best ways to truly settle into a new place is to explore its culinary scene. Fear not, fellow foodies, because Venice boasts a delightful array of restaurants to satisfy every craving. To help you navigate your new gastronomic landscape, here are 10 must-try spots that will quickly make you feel like a local:

For the Iconic Waterfront Experience: Sharky's on the Pier

You simply can't talk about dining in Venice without mentioning Sharky's. Perched right on the Gulf of Mexico, the views here are as breathtaking as the fresh seafood. Whether you're digging into their famous grouper sandwich, enjoying perfectly grilled mahi-mahi, or sipping a sunset cocktail, Sharky's offers the quintessential Florida dining experience. It's the perfect spot to bring visiting family and friends for that classic Venice vibe. (For an upgraded experience make a reservation at their sister restaurant - Fins).

What to try: The Grouper Sandwich, Gulf Shrimp, any of their daily fresh catch specials.

Here's their website: https://www.sharkysonthepier.com/

For a Taste of Italy (Naturally!): Cassariano Italian Eatery

In a city named Venice, you'd expect some fantastic Italian food, and Cassariano delivers. This elegant yet comfortable eatery offers authentic regional Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From their homemade pasta to their flavorful seafood preparations and delectable desserts, Cassariano provides a true taste of Italy right here in Venice. It's ideal for a special occasion or a simply delicious night out.

What to try: Any of their homemade pasta dishes (check the specials!), the Osso Buco, the Tiramisu.

Here's their website: https://cassariano.com/

For Casual Comfort Food with a Local Twist: Dockside Waterfront Grill

Located right on the Intracoastal Waterway, Dockside offers a relaxed atmosphere with fantastic water views and a menu packed with crowd-pleasers. From juicy burgers and fresh salads to tasty seafood baskets and daily specials, Dockside is a reliable spot for a casual lunch or dinner. Watching the boats go by while you eat adds to the charm.

What to try: The Dockside Burger, the Fish and Chips, their daily soup specials.

Here's their website: https://docksidewaterfrontgrill.com/

For a Flavorful Fiesta: Mi Pueblo Mexican Restaurant

When you're craving vibrant flavors and a lively atmosphere, Mi Pueblo is the place to go. Their extensive menu features all your Mexican favorites, from sizzling fajitas and cheesy enchiladas to flavorful tacos and refreshing margaritas. The colorful decor and friendly service make for a fun and satisfying dining experience.

What to try: The Fajitas (chicken, steak, or shrimp), the Carnitas, their classic Margaritas.

Here's their website: https://www.mipueblomexican.com/

For a Sophisticated Steakhouse Experience: Prime Serious Steak & Seafood

If you're in the mood for a perfectly cooked steak or some upscale seafood, Prime Serious Steak & Seafood won't disappoint. With its elegant ambiance and attentive service, Prime is a great choice for a special celebration or a more refined dining experience. Their wine list is also noteworthy.

What to try: Any of their prime cuts of steak, the Chilean Sea Bass, their selection of oysters.

Here's their website: https://primeserioussteak.com/newsite/

 

For a Delicious Breakfast or Lunch: Original Word of Mouth

Start your day right or enjoy a satisfying lunch at The Blue Rooster. This local favorite is known for its hearty breakfast options, tasty sandwiches, fresh salads, and friendly service. It's a popular spot with locals for a reason – the food is consistently good, and the atmosphere is welcoming.

What to try: Their Eggs Benedict, Scone of the day and their smoothie of the day.

Here's their website: https://www.originalwordofmouth.com/

or Pizza That Hits the Spot: Giuseppe's Ristorante & Pizzeria

Sometimes, all you need is a really good pizza, and Giuseppe's delivers just that. Their authentic Italian pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and cooked in a traditional oven, resulting in a crispy crust and flavorful toppings. They also offer pasta dishes and other Italian specialties.

What to try: Any of their wood-fired pizzas, the Lasagna, the Caprese Salad.

Here's their website: https://www.giuseppesofvenice.com/

 For Local Flavors and Fresh Finds: Seed & Bean Market

Okay, this isn't strictly a sit-down restaurant, but Seed & Bean Market is a MUST-VISIT for new residents who appreciate fresh, local, and often organic options. While you can grab amazing coffee and treats here, they also offer a fantastic selection of prepared foods, sandwiches, salads, and grab-and-go meals made with high-quality ingredients. It's perfect for a quick and healthy lunch, stocking up for a picnic at the beach, or discovering local artisanal products. Plus, their coffee and baked goods are top-notch!

What to try: Their gourmet sandwiches, fresh salads, locally sourced produce, and definitely their coffee and any of their daily baked goods.

Here's a link to their site: https://seedandbeanmarket.com/

For a Sweet Treat and Coffee: Upper Crust Cafe & Bakery

Located right on West Venice Avenue, Upper Crust Cafe & Bakery is a beloved local spot known for its incredible baked goods, delicious breakfast and lunch options, and cozy atmosphere. From their famous scones with Devonshire cream to their flavorful sandwiches and quiches, Upper Crust uses fresh ingredients and offers a warm and welcoming experience. It's the perfect place to grab a coffee and pastry, enjoy a leisurely breakfast, or pick up some treats to enjoy at home.

What to try: Their delicious scones with Devonshire cream, the Banana Bread French Toast, the Lox & Cream Cheese Bagel, any of their fresh-baked pastries, and their daily breakfast and lunch specials.

Here's their website: https://uppercrustvenice.com/menu/

For Authentic and Aromatic Thai Cuisine: Paya Thai Curry

When your taste buds are yearning for the vibrant flavors of Thailand, Paya Thai Curry is a fantastic choice. This cozy and inviting restaurant offers a wide array of authentic Thai dishes, from fragrant curries and flavorful noodle dishes to delicious stir-fries and aromatic soups. Using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, Paya Thai Curry delivers a genuine taste of Thailand right here in Venice. It's a great spot for a flavorful and satisfying meal.

This is just a starting point, of course! Venice has many other fantastic restaurants waiting to be discovered. So, get out there, explore, and let your taste buds guide you. Welcome to the neighborhood – we hope you enjoy the delicious journey ahead!

What to try: Any of their flavorful curries, the Pad Thai, the Tom Yum soup.

Here's their website: https://www.payathaicurry.com/

 

agent
April Mackey Iliff

Agent

+1(720) 201-7526 | april@theiliffgroup.com

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message